Walt’s Fish Market – Restaurant and Tiki Bar
Renowned as one of the best restaurants in Sarasota, Walt’s serves premium, fresh seafood and has been an institution for over 100 years. Their success is partly due to the seafood market inside the restaurant, ensuring that meals consist of the freshest catches. Each day, local fishermen deliver an array of fish, shellfish, and crustaceans, making it available for immediate enjoyment. Walt’s is located at 4144 S. Tamiami Trail.
Shakespeare English Pub
Unassumingly tucked away in a shopping center off Osprey Ave., Shakespeare’s is an English pub-style restaurant adored by locals. Simple but flavorful favorites like the Spicy English Beer Dip—made with cheddar cheese, English ale, spices, and green onions—and gourmet specialty burgers keep customers coming back. With its cozy, classic English pub atmosphere, a wide selection of beer, and quality fare, Shakespeare’s is a must-visit. The pub is located at 3550 S. Osprey Ave.
JR’s Old Packinghouse Cafe
Voted a finalist for best Cuban Sandwich by USA Today and awarded the #1 Reader’s Choice by the Herald-Tribune for lunch and dinner specials, JR’s is celebrated for affordability, quality, and entertainment. Although it opened in 1999, making it relatively young for an “old-school” list, JR’s supports local musicians, keeping customers entertained while enjoying hearty dishes. JR’s is located at 987 S. Packinghouse Rd.
New Pass Grill and Bait Shop
A Sarasota landmark since 1929, New Pass Grill and Bait Shop combines a restaurant, bait and tackle shop, and boat tours with stunning views. Known for everything from chicken salad to fresh grouper sandwiches, this spot satisfies a range of tastes. Locals particularly enjoy the breakfast sandwiches and burritos—ideal for beach or boat days. New Pass is located at 1505 Ken Thompson Pkwy.
Yoder’s Amish Village
Yoder’s has delighted Sarasota residents since 1975. Known for its comforting, home-cooked feel, Yoder’s serves award-winning pies, fried chicken, and pot roasts. The meats and cheeses, traditionally prepared and brought in from Pennsylvania and Ohio, contribute to the authentic Amish cooking experience. Customers praise the generous portions, reasonable prices, and friendly service. Yoder’s is located at 3434 Bahia Vista St.
Hurricane Hank’s
Hurricane Hank’s, located at 5346 Gulf Dr, Holmes Beach, has been recognized by the Sarasota Herald-Tribune as Sarasota and Bradenton’s “best hidden gem restaurant” in this article. Tucked away in the S&S Plaza on Anna Maria Island, this unassuming spot offers a casual atmosphere that belies the exceptional quality of its dishes. Patrons rave about the bacon-wrapped scallops, grouper piccata, and the indulgent banana & bourbon cheesecake. These standout items showcase the culinary excellence that has earned Hurricane Hank’s its esteemed reputation. For a complete overview of their offerings, you can view their menu.
